Federal Court Removes Swine Slaughter Line Speed Provision

A federal court has removed a provision of the New Swine Slaughter Inspection System (NSIS) that enabled pork processors to establish maximum line speeds. The lawsuit, brought against the USDA by the United Food and Commercial Workers Union and three of its local chapters, challenged the 2019 rule change, arguing that faster slaughter speeds undermined worker safety.

On March 31, the U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota ruled that the Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) of the USDA violated the Administrative Procedures Act (APA) when the agency failed to consider whether increasing line speeds would harm workers.

President Joe Biden's administration, which pledges to prioritize worker safety, quickly withdrew a Trump administration proposal to allow all poultry plants to operate faster-than-established line speed limits, Reuters reports. But reversing the pork rule was expected to be more challenging, because it was already in effect.

A USDA spokesperson told Reuters the agency is reviewing the court decision "closely in light of the authorities, mission and mandate of the Food Safety and Inspection Service."

Additionally, the court placed a 90-day stay on its order to allow USDA time to develop a plan with respect to those plants that have converted to NSIS.

The North American Meat Institute (Meat Institute) said, ““The Meat Institute is disappointed in the ruling, especially following the 20 years of study through the pilot, the HACCP-Based Inspection Model Project (HIMP). The Meat Institute offered compelling evidence about the safety of workers in HIMP/NSIS in our amicus brief. For these reasons, we would like to see the agency appeal and ask for a stay.”

United Food and Commercial Workers International (UFCW) and Public Citizen, both opponents of NSIS, claimed this decision as a victory for worker safety.

“America’s essential workers in pork plants across the country have put their health and safety at risk every day during this pandemic to help families put food on the table,” said Marc Perrone, UFCW International president, in a release. “Today’s ruling is a victory for all of these brave men and women, finally ending the dangerous Trump USDA policy that allowed pork plants to push workers to the breaking point with unsafe line speeds that increase the risk of injury and put the safety of our food supply in jeopardy.”

The pork industry applauded the USDA in September 2019 for introducing the new inspection system after many years of research and evaluation. It received the endorsement of the National Association of Federal Veterinarians, highlighting the strong science-based approach used in designing the program.

More from Farm Journal's PORK:

Union Representing Pork Processing Plant Workers Sues USDA



Latest News

Patience Pays Off When Treating BRD

To stay on top of Bovine Respiratory Disease (BRD), producers find patience and persistence are two assets they need in their treatment plans.

Hulett: Packers Push for More Cattle

The spring rally in negotiated cash cattle prices continued last week as trade in the South developed early in the week with packers more aggressive than in recent weeks.

Total Quality Management – A Foundational Approach of BQA

Established product requirements in the beef industry may differ somewhat from one segment of the industry to the next, but there are some common expectations fundamental to each.

Divestment plan leads to ownership changes for 11 feedlots
Peel: Update on Beef Export Markets

Beef exports have evolved significantly in a very dynamic environment of global politics and trade policies; direct and indirect impacts of animal disease outbreaks; and growing beef preferences and consumption.

Carbon Contract Reality: Why Conservation-Minded Farmers May Not Qualify for Private Carbon Programs

The chase to capture carbon continues. It’s a possible new source of income for farmers and ranchers, but it's also bringing a set of challenges and questions. The answer could be both public and private programs.

Cattle Markets Surge Higher In Spring Rally

The reopening of restaurant and foodservice is driving beef demand to pre-pandemic levels and beyond, spiking wholesale beef prices $20 per cwt. higher this week, and more than $34 per cwt. higher over two weeks.