Speer: Cow Inventory And Producers’ Share

.
.
(Hall & Hall)

Beef Cow Inventory:  The cow herd has been the primary focus of the past several columns – including the most recent one explaining the following: 

“The critics will keep pointing to waning cow numbers – contending it’s an indication of the business’ demise...[but] cow inventory is NOT a reliable proxy of the industry’s viability.   Things aren’t always what they seem.”

Just as that column was nearing the finish line, I had some correspondence regarding producers’ share of the retail dollar and what that ultimately means for the industry over the long run.  As such, it’s useful to explore the two measures (beef cow inventory and producers’ share) simultaneously because both are often referenced by those critical of the industry’s innerworkings.    Nevil chart

Producers’ Share:  As quick review, the measure isn’t very meaningful.   Dr. Brester (Montana State University) et al. point out investment by processors and retailers to enhance demand inherently reduces producers’ share.  However, that investment ultimately makes the industry better off over the long run. 

That is, the pie gets bigger.  But producers’ share doesn’t reflect that occurrence over time.  Rather, it represents sectors antagonistically - “as competitors for a fixed value, rather than as partners in the production of greater value.”  (For more on this concept, see Pan Beats Knife)

Cow Herd:  Let’s now come back to beef cow inventory.   The argument generally goes something like this: 1) the packer has too much power, 2) the market is broken, 3) fed prices are too low, and 4) calf prices suffer as a result and too many producers are quitting the business.   Therefore, a negative turn in producers’ share ultimately drives sell-off at the farm or ranch level.  

The graph below addresses that line of logic   Note the direction of the correlation; it contrasts the reasoning outlined above.  Most important, the relationship is weak; that’s further demonstrated within the table outlined below; over the span of five decades the distribution of inventory change versus producers’ share is well balanced.   spear chart

What’s It All Mean?:  An editorial last fall asked, “…how many producers and small feedlots are going to go out of business before our elected representatives do something?”  The permabears contend:  one, producers’ share is eroding margins available to the production sector; two, declining cow numbers represent the ultimate manifestation of that reality.  And seemingly it’s all very sinister. 

However, as noted in a previous column:  

Substantial gains have resulted from enduring commitment to better quality, improved consistency and enhanced promotion. As a result, beef spending has outpaced the competition since 2000. The beef industry has recaptured market share and cattle prices have risen as a result. Singular focus on farmers’ share misses that favorable outcome.    

In the end, the only measures that really matter center around beef demand and consumer spending (see Keep The Main Thing The Main Thing).   In tandem, they prove to be the ultimate indicator, and driver, of prosperity.

 

 

Latest News

Biden Administration Restores Wildlife Protections
Biden Administration Restores Wildlife Protections

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service plans to reinstate rules protecting endangered plants and animals, action that would reverse changes made during the Trump Administration that weakened the Endangered Species Act.

Across Breed EPD Adjustment Factors
Across Breed EPD Adjustment Factors

EPDs from multiple breeds can be compared by adding/subtracting the appropriate adjustment factors to the EPDs resulting from the most recent genetic evaluations for each of 18 breeds.

APHIS Now Thinks Wild Birds Are to Blame for Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza's Arrival on Four U.S. Dairies
APHIS Now Thinks Wild Birds Are to Blame for Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza's Arrival on Four U.S. Dairies

The livestock industry continues to grapple with the first confirmed cases of HPAI in cattle, while federal and state agencies continue to assure consumers there's no concern about the safety of the U.S. milk supply.

Skills Survey Reveals U.S. Agriculture & Food Industry Workforce Needs and Gaps
Skills Survey Reveals U.S. Agriculture & Food Industry Workforce Needs and Gaps

U.S. employers report challenges in finding suitable job candidates with work-ready skills to fill open roles in ag. The AgCareers.com U.S. Skills Survey offers insights, data and trends to address skill development.

USDA Authorizes CRP Graze and Hay Donations to Wildfire Victims
USDA Authorizes CRP Graze and Hay Donations to Wildfire Victims

Conservation Reserve Program (CRP) participants can donate emergency grazing authority to ranchers in Nebraska, Oklahoma and Texas impacted by recent wildfires.

New Guide Helps Producers Maximize Values of Cull Cows
New Guide Helps Producers Maximize Values of Cull Cows

A new resource developed by the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association and CattleFax helps cattle producers maximize profitability from their culling decisions.