Cattle Markets Have Topped, Entering Recalibration Phase

CattleFax CEO Randy Blach details why $30/cwt. of recent market highs stemmed from temporary trade policies — and why cow-calf producers will hold margins better than feedyards.

IMG_0648.jpg
(Kansas Livestock Association)

Cattle markets are recalibrating after a historic, record-setting run, and cattle feeders and stocker operators face a demanding 12 to 18 months ahead, CattleFax CEO Randy Blach warns.

Blach urges the sector to recognize that recent market highs were fueled not only by structural supply shortages, but also by short-term policy shocks that are now unwinding.

“We’re at the top right now. We’re at the top of our game as an industry,” Blach says at the Kansas Livestock Association membership breakfast Nov. 20 in Manhattan, Kan. “We have to have a reality check. Everybody in the room needs to understand what was real and what wasn’t real — what was fluff. But I want to make sure we all understand why we got so high, and what happens from here.”

Unpacking the $30 “Policy Premium”

Blach is direct about the mechanics behind recent price spikes: while underlying cattle supplies were tight, government trade policies added artificial market heat.

Blach estimates the temporary closure of the Mexican border to cattle imports added approximately $18/cwt. to fed-cattle values. Tariffs on beef from competitors such as Brazil tacked on another $12/cwt. In total, roughly $30/cwt. of recent fed-cattle pricing was driven by policy intervention rather than sustainable baseline supply and demand.

As policy-driven distortions clear and future supply gains loom on the horizon, markets have begun to reset.

“Why did our market go from $2.65 on May 1 to $2.15 last week?” Blach asks. “The market is having to go back and buy demand back for the supply increase it sees coming down the road.”

Supply Is Turning: Three Sources of Growth

Blach points to three distinct drivers that will gradually rebuild slaughter volumes over the coming years:

  1. U.S. Beef Cow Expansion: Low cow slaughter rates and rising heifer retention indicate cow-calf producers are entering an expansion phase. Improved moisture across Texas and the Southwest could accelerate this recovery if weather patterns hold.
  2. Reopening of Mexican Cattle Imports: Prior to border disruptions, the U.S. imported roughly 1.2 million head of Mexican feeder cattle annually. Volume collapsed to approximately 200,000 head during the border closure. Blach expects imports to rebound to roughly 800,000 head next year and approach normalized levels within 12 months. “The cattle are worth more here than they are there,” Blach says. “When the border was closed, those cattle were bringing 30% to 50% of U.S. market value.”
  3. The Permanent Beef-Dairy Cross Influx: Dairy-beef crosses now represent a structural transformation in fed cattle supplies rather than a temporary anomaly.

The Beef-Dairy Cross Revolution

What began as an opportunistic crossbreeding trend has become a permanent pillar of the feedyard supply chain.

“Nearly one in four of the animals we have in our feedyards today are dairy-influenced cattle,” Blach notes. “They’ll be 21% to 22% of our fed slaughter this year, compared to about 15% at the peak of the last cattle cycle.”

With beef-dairy calves now generating roughly 25% of overall dairy operation revenue, the economics firmly favor continued breeding. Furthermore, these cattle consistently produce high carcass quality: “In many cases, they’ll grade superior to what we would see out of some of our native cows if the genetics are right,” he says.

Segment Margins: Cow-Calf Still Strong, Feeders in the Squeeze

Blach maps out where profitability will fall across sectors as the market transitions toward a cyclical low in 2026 — mirroring the cycle low seen in 2015:

  • Cow-Calf Operators: Projected to remain the most profitable sector. While calf prices are likely to ease from historic peaks, Blach forecasts 2027 calf prices to remain in the lower $4 range. “We’re still going to make good money on our calves,” Blach notes.
  • Cattle Feeders & Stockers: Face a severe margin test over the next 12 to 18 months. Elevated break-evens, high feeder-placement costs, and market volatility (typically spanning ±10% around average prices) make strict risk management essential.

Blach issues a special warning regarding feedyard days on feed, which have risen from an average of 132 days in 1985 to roughly 203 days today. Feedyards currently hold a record number of cattle on feed for more than 180 days. A winter weather disruption or sudden push to liquidate could trigger a sharp, short-term supply bottleneck and depress cash prices.

Looking ahead, Blach forecasts fed cattle to average around $220 to $225/cwt. in 2027, with the subsequent cyclical low expected around 2031 to 2032 — a floor he expects will remain substantially higher than previous historical lows.

Quality: Defending Market Share of the Wallet

Blach urges the beef industry to protect the eating quality gains that revived domestic demand over the past two decades. Today, approximately 88% of fed cattle grade USDA Choice or Prime, compared to the 1990s and early 2000s when “one or two steaks out of every four was a poor eating experience.”

However, he cautions against pushing cattle to excessive endpoints:

  • Overfat Carcasses: An estimated 30% to 35% of the current fed cattle supply is grading Yield Grade 4. “We’re making them too big,” Blach says. “We need to identify the genetics and EPDs to build these cattle without feeding them to these maximum endpoints.”
  • Global Competition: Competitors in Australia, Brazil and Argentina are increasingly feeding cattle longer and challenging U.S. dominance in high-quality, grain-fed export markets.
  • Changing Consumer Habits: While poultry dominates protein consumption by volume (holding 52% of the market vs. beef’s 26%), beef captures 52% of consumer protein spending. Shifts in consumer health habits — including the rise of GLP-1 weight-loss medications — show shoppers opting for smaller portions of premium, nutrient-dense protein. “Which do you want?” Blach challenges. “52% market share of stomach, or 52% market share of wallet?”

He concludes, “What a run. Some of it was fundamentals, and some of it was policy. We’re going to roll over again — and we’ve got to remember where we came from to stay focused on where we’re going.”

    Drovers_Logo_No-Tagline (1632x461)
    Drovers_Logo_No-Tagline (1632x461)
    Read Next
    With one-third of fed cattle grading Yield Grade 4 or 5 and packers preparing 3D imaging rollouts, Lee Leachman and James Henderson share what commercial ranchers must do now to prepare.
    Get News Daily
    Get Market Alert
    Get News & Markets App