For years, the cash cattle market and value-based pricing grids have sent producers a loud, unambiguous signal: make them heavier, make them fatter, and make them grade Choice or Prime. The industry delivered. But that single-minded pursuit of pounds and marbling has created excessive waste fat and declining retail cutability, a massive, unintended consequence hanging in packing plant coolers across the U.S. Today, roughly one-third of the fed cattle population falls into Yield Grade (YG) 4 and 5.
The science has been laid out. The CT scanner data is in. The packing plants are installing 3D cameras. Now comes the question that every producer needs to answer: What do I actually do?
James Henderson of Bradley 3 Ranch, Memphis, Texas, and Lee Leachman of Leachman Cattle, Meriden, Wyo., have advocated for a modernized yield grading system and are preparing for the changes it means for their bull customers.
“I think one of the major packers is going to be ready to start providing that information back to their vendors by the first of January,” says Henderson, a former packing plant executive with 35 years in the processing sector. “It’s probably going to be here quicker than maybe we’ve been prepared for.”
With a 27-month lag between the day a bull is selected and the day his steer progeny hangs on the rail, the breeding decisions made this spring will be marketed under this new economic reality.
The $1,000 Hiding in Your Herd
The economic impetus driving packers toward 3D cameras and cutability-based grading comes down to cold, hard cutout value. On a recent episode of the I’m A Drover podcast, Henderson cites a Texas Tech University demonstration evaluating four steers of nearly identical live slaughter weights.
“When they were slaughtered and we’d run them through the CT scan and gotten all the data back, there was almost $1,000 difference in value of those four steers that had similar live weights,” Henderson explains. “Those are big numbers. Those are numbers that should get all of our attention. If there’s $1,000 that we might be leaving on the table as an industry, how much more efficient and cost-effective could we be?”
Currently, modest discounts on YG 4s allow feedyards to keep cattle on feed for 30 to 40 days past their optimal finish, capitalizing on cheap corn and heavy live weights. But Leachman notes feed conversion drops precipitously in late feeding stages as gain shifts almost entirely from muscle to subcutaneous waste fat.
“Like anything in livestock, if you don’t measure everything, unintended consequences usually are negative,” Leachman summarizes. “We’ve hurt the red meat yield on cattle probably significantly, and now we need to look at balancing it a little more towards red meat yield.”
The Ribeye Illusion: Why Single-Trait EPDs Fail Cutability
For more than three decades, commercial cattle producers and seedstock breeders have treated the ribeye area expected progeny difference (EPD) as the gold standard for adding muscle.
However, meat science research led by Dale Woerner delivers a humbling revelation: Ribeye area explains only 3% to 5% of the true variation in retail subprimal yield. Furthermore, traditional USDA yield grade equations explain only about one-third of cutability variation in native cattle.
Until genetic evaluations offer commercial cutability and red meat yield EPDs, what data points should bull buyers use?
Both Leachman and Henderson offer a surprisingly traditional answer: Trust your eyes.
“Most people in this business are pretty good cattlemen,” Henderson emphasizes. “Too much today, we may rely on numbers and EPDs and videos. Look at the cattle and study the cattle. If these bulls are narrow-based, if they don’t have shape in their rump, if they don’t express that muscle in the forearm, they’re probably not going to do well on red meat yield.”
Leachman agrees, adding his operation culls bull candidates that lack visual muscular expression. He advises cattle producers to evaluate three primary physical markers:
- Pronounced shape through the round. A thick, deep quarter and stifle that carries width down through the hock.
- Forearm muscle expression. Visible muscle circumference and bulge in the lower forearm.
- Length of body and moderate rrame. Avoiding extreme, framey cattle.
“Our initial data suggests that bigger-frame cattle are at a decided disadvantage because they have a lot more bone relative to the percentage of weight,” Leachman explains. “If an animal has 4% more bone, it’s hard to be competitive on red meat yield.”
Heterosis at Work: Balancing the 40-Cow Reality
In an ideal production model, commercial producers would split their herds into maternal and terminal lines — breeding moderate, easy-fleshing maternal cows to keep replacements on pasture and terminal bulls to generate heavy-muscled, lean carcass steers.
Yet, as Henderson points out, that is an unrealistic luxury for the majority of the U.S. beef herd. “A big part of our cattle population is in the hands of producers with 30 to 50 cows. When you’re talking that maybe you’ve got 15 or 20 steer calves, it’s not very easy for them to manage terminal and maternal herds.”
For producers running single-bull or small pastures who cannot split herds, Leachman advocates for hybrid or composite sires.
“We encourage them to use a hybrid bull — that bull that has between 3/8 and 5/8 of both British and Continental genetics,” Leachman says, noting U.S. Meat Animal Research Center (USMARC) in Clay Center, Neb., proved this balance decades ago. “Whether biased toward marbling with 5/8 British and 3/8 Continental, or toward muscle with 5/8 Continental, those half-and-half cattle do a better job balancing marbling and muscling than either straight British or straight Continental cattle.”
For purebred Angus breeders, Henderson notes selection for marbling and fertility often works in tandem. “Our data would show that cattle that marble well will rebreed. Marbling is transient; it’s one of those tools we can use and maybe not have quite as much back fat in those cattle, serving both functions.”
The Warning: Don’t Sacrifice Taste for Lean Mass
If there is one message they both want producers to hold onto, it is this: don’t swing to the extreme.
“We have to be careful not to overcompensate. We’ve always done that as an industry,” Leachman warns. “I would look for cattle that are going to start to do both, and just be careful not to swing to the extremes.”
He points to competing proteins as a cautionary tale.
“If you think about what happened in poultry and swine, they selected for lean mass and efficient lean mass, and they gave up taste. It has not served them well,” Leachman warns. “Consumers favor beef over poultry and pork by significant margins per pound because of eating consistency and marbling. As you design systems to get at red meat yield, you want to make sure that you’re not making $1 on red meat yield and giving up all the marbling.”
Henderson echoes that sentiment, reminding producers that moderation is the foundation of sustainability: “Extremes tend to always create grief and unintended consequences that sometimes as an industry we can’t afford. Moderation is truly the key.”
Sire Selection Checklist: Breeding for the New Cutability Era
Before buying bulls, here are five actionable strategies Leachman and Henderson suggest to help producers prepare for modernized yield grading:
- Don’t rely solely on ribeye area EPDs. Keep in mind that ribeye area accounts for less than 5% of true cutability. Don’t assume a high ribeye area number guarantees high-yielding calves.
- Evaluate muscle from the ground up. Look for wide-based bulls with natural width, thick expression through the stifle, round and down through the forearm.
- Avoid excessive frame and bone. Steer clear of raw-boned, tall cattle. Added bone percentage lowers retail cutability without contributing to sellable beef.
- Match strategy to herd size:
- Herds more than 150 cows: Consider splitting into maternal matings (protecting body condition and rebreeding) and high-cutability terminal sires.
- Herds less than 100 cows: Consider 3/8 to 5/8 British-Continental hybrid/composite bulls to capture heterosis and maintain dual-purpose balance.
- Protect marbling at all costs: Palatability is beef’s greatest competitive asset. Insist on genetics that hit Choice and Prime without requiring 40 excessive days of waste fat deposition in the feedyard.
🎧 Tune In Now: Listen to or watch episode two of the “I’m A Drover” podcast to learn how modern carcass cutability will transform cattle marketing — and what steps you must take to protect your herd’s profitability.
Your Next Reads:


