If you think the USDA yield grading system keeping your cattle priced is working as designed, Dale Woerner, a meat scientist, has news for you.
“We’re at a position now where we think we’re within two years of our industry moving forward and actually transacting carcasses using an online system for red meat yield that will replace the yield grade system,” Woerner says.
His message to producers who aren’t yet engaged?
“If you are not thinking about this, if this is not registering with you, it is registering with others, and the most progressive in our industry are making decisions on this already, and they have been for quite some time,” he stresses. “You’ll be in the bottom end of the procurement, the bottom end of the profitability sector if you’re not consciously looking at this moving forward.”
A System Built on 162 Head in 1962
So why is the yield grading system not working? The numbers are damning.
“The USDA yield grading system really spawned from the work of a guy named Charlie Murphy and his team at Texas A&M University,” Woerner explains. Research was published around 1960, the USDA equation was piloted as early as 1962 — and the sample size that formed the basis of the entire system? Just 162 head of cattle.
“I don’t think Charlie Murphy or any of the research team at that point in time, one, maybe even would have expected that only 162 head would serve as the official USDA yield grade, and two, most definitely didn’t think it would last 65 years,” Woerner says.
The cattle of today bear almost no resemblance to the ones Murphy studied. The system was developed from cattle that “would look like calves compared to the 1,500-lb. steers headed to packing plants today.” And the equation shows it.
“Cattle are too fat, and when we get on average fat thicknesses that are seven tenths or eight tenths, yield grades averaging in groups of cattle at four, you know that’s a problem,” says Woerner, Texas Tech University Cargill endowed professor in sustainable meat science and the lead researcher for the Beef Checkoff-funded red meat yield working group.
An Academic Failure — Literally
On a recent episode of the I’m A Drover podcast, Woerner unpacked why the system grading nearly every fed cattle carcass in America is broken — and what’s coming to replace it. When asked to evaluate how well the current yield grade equation predicts red meat yield on an individual carcass, he refuses to sugarcoat the diagnosis.
“We’ve had data sets where we’ve compared true red meat yield or saleable yield to yield grade that says there’s a 4% relationship,” he explains. “I think most of us are in agreement, however, that there’s somewhere around a 40% to about 55% relationship between calculated yield grade and saleable yield outcomes. So we’re performing in that failing rate or academic F, if you will, failure from 40% to 55% in how that yield grade equation is performing.”
The practical consequence: the industry simply cannot send accurate market signals upstream to the producers and feeders who need them.
“Not only are we struggling with procurement and true value in carcasses, but we’re not telling the producer, the feeder, how to correct the problem that we have,” he emphasizes.
The Ribeye Myth
For decades — from 4-H meat judging books to sire selection manuals — ribeye area has been the gold standard for assessing carcass muscling. Woerner’s research challenges that assumption head-on.
“Ribeye area truthfully is the only single muscling trait in the current yield grade equation, so it made sense for our industry to pursue ribeye area in a positive way to improve yield grade,” he says. “Problem is, the yield grade didn’t reflect the changes with ribeye changes in muscling, and that’s because ribeye in all of the data that we have today is independent from total carcass muscling.”
Worse, decades of single-trait selection may have made things worse.
“When we propagate genetics with big ribeyes, but without corresponding carcass muscling, then we actually take that trait in a negative direction,” Woerner says.
And ironically, the ribeye itself has gotten too big.
“It’s high 14s, approaching 15 square inches on average in carcasses, which is too big,” he stresses. “Retailers and food service operators are saying that they cannot sell a ribeye that large at a standard one-inch thick cut of steak to consumers.”
The CT Scanner on a Semi-Trailer
The solution Woerner and his team are building is as dramatic as the problem it’s solving. They configured a commercial medical CT scanner inside a semi-trailer.
“We back it into the plant,” he explains. “The plants that we’ve collaborated with have allowed for us to quarter those carcasses, so the hind quarter and forequarter, and we’re able to scan those through the machine one at a time and capture data.”
The results are extraordinary.
“We’re able to measure muscle, fat and bone with near perfect accuracy. So it would be like taking that carcass apart with a scalpel, right, and separating muscle, fat, and bone, in tiny fragments or pieces.”
While CT scanning is too slow for commercial line speeds, Woerner notes it provides the benchmark to train technology that will replace yield grades. In fact, fully automated 3D imaging systems are already being installed in packing plants.
“These systems are going to get an A,” he explains. “The 3D systems have clear potential to predict 90% or more of the variation in carcass composition and saleable yield.”
And instead of Yield Grades 1 through 5, the future grading system will likely operate on a continuous, percentage-based standard — measuring, for example, the carcass that yields a 65% saleable portion.
🎧 Tune In Now: Listen to or watch episode two of the “I’m A Drover” podcast to learn how modern carcass cutability will transform cattle marketing — and what steps you must take to protect your herd’s profitability.
Your Next Reads:


