Chronic Wasting Disease: Don’t Panic, but Remain Vigilant

So far, there has been no strong evidence that CWD can cross species barriers to affect cattle through typical environmental exposure, or for that matter, humans who consume meat from infected cervids.
So far, there has been no strong evidence that CWD can cross species barriers to affect cattle through typical environmental exposure, or for that matter, humans who consume meat from infected cervids.
(John Maday)

The following commentary does not necessarily reflect the views of AgWeb or Farm Journal. The opinions expressed below are the author's own.

The issue of chronic wasting disease (CWD) in deer and other cervids continues to worry stakeholders including hunters, deer farmers and businesses that generate revenue from deer hunting and related activities. And because of its similarity to Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE), concerns have lingered that CWD could eventually could spread to cattle.

Scientists have studied and monitored CWD since its discovery in Colorado in the 1960s, and although the disease has continued to spread and cause significant death loss in wild and captive cervid herds, some studies indicate it will remain relatively rate and is unlikely to affect humans or livestock. Nevertheless, ranchers and veterinarians should watch for signs of CWD in deer and quickly investigate any unknown neurological disease in cattle.  

A new report from the American Cervid Alliance (ACA), titled “Current Scientific Knowledge about CWD,” compiles research results and CWD trends, and the authors suggest the problem might be less severe than commonly believed. It is important to note that the American Cervid Alliance primarily represents deer farmers and related businesses.

The authors maintain that some of the high estimates of CWD prevalence in affected states, some as high as 40%, have been based on modeling, rather than actual field data. They say CWD is a fairly rare disease with a prevalence less than 1% in over one million deer tested nationally over the last 20 years, and a prevalence of 11% in the 196 CWD-positive counties in the 23 CWD positive States.

So far, there has been no strong evidence that CWD can cross species barriers to affect cattle through typical environmental exposure, or for that matter, humans who consume meat from infected cervids.

The ACA report cites the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) noting that the CWD prion has been shown to experimentally infect squirrel monkeys and also laboratory mice that carry some human genes. Canadian and German researchers have reported transmission to macaque monkeys consuming infected meat or brain tissue from infected cervids. They also have infected macaques by injecting infectious material into their brains. In other studies, however, scientists have not successfully transmitted the disease to macaques.

As for cattle, recent results from a long-term exposure trial now support the belief that the lethal prion disease is highly unlikely to cross the species barrier. In this 10-year trial, researchers from the University of Wyoming’s Wyoming State Veterinary Laboratory (WSVL), the Colorado Division of Parks and Wildlife and the Wyoming Game and Fish Department (WGFD) collaborated to expose groups of cattle to high levels of CWD prions. The researchers exposed cattle to CWD using two methods and in different locations in Colorado, Wyoming and at the USDA’s National Animal Disease Center in Ames, Iowa. One group of 12 calves received an initial oral dose of brain material from CWD-infected mule deer, with five un-inoculated cattle serving controls.

Two other groups of cattle spent 10 years housed in outdoor pens with CWD-infected mule deer or elk, with continuous exposure through feed, water and direct contact.

At the end of the trial, the researchers euthanized and examined all the surviving cattle. None of the cattle showed any sign of CWD or any neurological pathology during the trial period or at necropsy.Read more about that study in “Cattle Resist CWD in Long-Term Trial.”

In contrast, an earlier study at Colorado State University documented how even mild exposure can result in infection among deer. The researchers confined three groups of three CWD-naïve mule deer in pens either occupied by CWD-infected animals two years earlier, pens with CWD carcass and pes with a CWD infected animal. A total of 16% of the CWD-naïve deer in the three experimental conditions in nine pens became infected.

According to the ACA report, a review of the literature based on actual data shows that that “any past combination of quarantines, containment zones, surveillance zones, depopulation, elective harvest, increased harvest limits, supplemental feeding bans, baiting bans, bans on the importation of live cervid species, bans on the importation, of carcasses, bans on the importation of trophies, and bans on urine based lures, have not been effective in preventing, controlling, or eradicating CWD in any State.”

While that might be true, research, surveillance and control efforts, including preventive regulations and biosecurity for captive cervid herds should continue. While the damage so far has remained limited, the disease has potential to negatively impact rural economies even if it remains only in cervids. If the disease ever does cross the species barrier to other ruminants such as cattle, economic losses could be substantial.



Latest News

Research Highlights: The State of the Current Beef Consumer

This white paper, put together by the National Cattlemen's Beef Association, offers a snapshot of how domestic consumers have responded to the unprecedented events of 2020 as well as a long-term outlook. 

2 hours ago
Ben Tyner
Missing B.C. Rancher’s Family Offers Reward

Wyoming native Ben Tyner disappeared two years ago from the British Columbia ranch he was managing. His family released a video asking the public for information.

2 hours ago
Newborn calf
Selk: Calving Assistance During And After Stage II

Despite our best efforts at bull selection and heifer development, cows or heifers occasionally need assistance at calving time. Here are recommendations on when to provide calving assistance for cows and heifers.

7 hours ago
Winter bale grazing
North Dakota To Consider Voluntary Checkoff

A North Dakota state representative has introduced legislation that would make the state's additional $1 beef checkoff voluntary. It would have no impact on the national Beef Checkoff.

1 day ago
Greg Hanes: What Have You Done for Me Lately?

In this commentary Greg Hanes, CEO of the Cattlemen's Beef Board, discusses the ways that Beef Checkoff dollars have been used in the past few months.

1 day ago
Cattle and hog feeding
Profit Tracker: Steady In The Red

Cattle and hog feeding margins were little changed last week, with both recording modest losses. Beef packers saw improved margins on significant gains in wholesale beef prices.

1 day ago