“Targeted” Law in Iowa Ruled Unconstitutional by Federal Judge

Iowa’s second ‘ag-gag’ law, creating criminal charges for those who gain access to an agricultural facility using deception for the purpose of causing physical or economic harm, has been ruled unconstitutional by a federal judge.
Iowa’s second ‘ag-gag’ law, creating criminal charges for those who gain access to an agricultural facility using deception for the purpose of causing physical or economic harm, has been ruled unconstitutional by a federal judge.
(Canva.com)

Iowa’s second ‘ag-gag’ law has been ruled unconstitutional by a federal judge. This specific law created criminal charges for those who gained access to an agricultural facility using deception for the purpose of causing physical or economic harm.

Iowa has passed four laws since 2012 in response to animal rights activists who have published images and video from inside agricultural facilities, sometimes infiltrating them by getting hired as employees, according to the Des Moines Register (DMR).

U.S. District Judge Stephanie Rose told DMR that this particular law “impermissibly distinguishes between animal rights activists and others who might lie to gain access to facilities for other reasons.” In addition, Rose explained that the law singled out individuals based on their point of view and the government cannot regulate speech of a certain viewpoint due to First Amendment rights.

Similar laws have been seen in several states, including Idaho, Kansas, Utah, Wyoming, Arkansas and North Carolina, many of which have been tried in court under similar pretenses.

Iowa Pork Producers Association attorney, Eldon McAfee told DMR that courts have been “walking a fine line” in writing the statutes, in part because courts in different parts of the country have disagreed on key constitutional questions. Some laws have been struck down due to being “overbroad” and "now this court is saying very strongly that this law is too narrow, too targeted, aimed at the plaintiffs in this case," McAfee said.

Of the four laws in Iowa, the first, second and fourth laws have all been challenged in court. The state has the option to appeal this decision.

 

Latest News

AFIA Objects to EPA’s Draft Risk Evaluation of Formaldehyde
AFIA Objects to EPA’s Draft Risk Evaluation of Formaldehyde

The American Feed Industry Association says formaldehyde has been "safely used in the U.S. animal food industry for over 40 years via accurate automated equipment."

Power of Meat Reports Strong Meat Consumption, Evolving Consumer Trends
Power of Meat Reports Strong Meat Consumption, Evolving Consumer Trends

The Meat Institute and FMI-The Food Industry Association released the 19th annual Power of Meat report.

Cattle Imports from Mexico
Cattle Imports from Mexico

Mexico has become one of the major beef import sources for the U.S. as beef trade evolved from simply supplementing deficit beef production in Mexico to bilateral, product specific trade between the two countries.

Markets: Cash Cattle Markets Nearing Historic Highs
Markets: Cash Cattle Markets Nearing Historic Highs

All classes of cattle sold at higher prices for the week and most are at or near record highs. Supplies of all classes remain extremely tight.

International Genetic Solutions Debuts New Informational Resource
International Genetic Solutions Debuts New Informational Resource

International Genetic Solutions (IGS) recently unveiled a new information resource and video platform for important beef industry topics pertinent to producers’ bottom lines.

Sage_Grouse_Booming
Ranchers Urge BLM to Incorporate Latest Science in New Sage Grouse Plans

NCBA and PLC are requesting that BLM significantly extend the comment period deadlines while ranchers and other local stakeholders evaluate these lengthy proposals.