Speer: Is Fair What We Really Want?

.
.
(AHA)

Last month’s column highlighted the cost of market mandates to producers.  But when the market gets stuck, it’s easy to get sidetracked by emotion and lose focus on broader economic principles.  Nevertheless, mandates always lead to unintended consequences – particularly if government begins to meddle with the consumer. 

That’s where we now find Secretary Vilsack; he’s surrendered to the emotion swirling in the market.  In early-September, he outlined new USDA priorities that include making “…sure that when consumers go to the grocery store and they’re at the checkout counter, they get fairer prices.”  Thus, there’s now prospect of new regulatory measures geared towards the retail side of the business. 

History provides many relevant lessons of just how detrimental that could be. But one example is especially fitting here.  In 1887, Congress created the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) to regulate rail carriers. The agency deemed freight and passenger rates “shall be reasonable and just.”    

Implementation of price controls proved counter-effective - encouraging (versus deterring) collusion among competitors. Moreover, regulatory oversight became so burdensome railroads were actually prevented from abandoning unprofitable lines and established ridiculous incentives that hurt consumers. For instance, some narrow- gauge railroads began purchasing standard rail (8’ long) instead of narrow-gauge ties (6’-to-7’ in length).  The longer rail ties were more costly and artificially inflated annual operating costs. The practice was intended to obtain governmental approval to raise consumer prices (in perpetuity - without any improvement in service).

Conversely, there’s a different type of history lesson that can be applied here.  It’s a story of remarkable turnaround and one in which both consumers and producers benefit - all without government regulation.    Best of all, it comes from the beef industry. 

Between 1980-and-1998 (when beef demand bottomed out) beef fell woefully behind its competitors.  For nearly twenty years, new spending on beef was flat (which subsequently prevented cattle prices from improving).  Meanwhile, pork and poultry successfully grew new spending by nearly $110/person.  

But all that began to turn around when the industry got serious about the consumer.  Substantial gains have resulted from enduring commitment to better quality, improved consistency and enhanced promotion. Consumers have access to greater differentiation and higher-quality beef products now, more than ever.  As a result, beef spending has outpaced the competition since 2000. The beef industry has recaptured market share and cattle prices have risen as a result. (See chart.) Consumer spending

But now the Administration is giving traction to all the noise and overlooking the beef industry’s long-run success story.  For whatever reason, Mr. Vilsack wants to promote disruption of free markets and voluntary exchange with more governmental oversight – all in the name of “fairness”. No one flourishes with that sort of approach.    

Making government the referee never goes well – nor ever really facilitates fairness.  Mandates cost producers and penalize consumers. Effort towards how the pie gets sliced is wasted motion.  Instead, continued success and prosperity for producers – and ever-increasing options for consumers – results only from making the pie bigger.

Nevil Speer is based in Bowling Green, KY and serves as Director of Industry Relations for Where Food Comes From (WFCF).  The views and opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect those of WFCF or its shareholders.  He can be reached at nspeer@wherefoodcomesfrom.com.  

 

Latest News

AFIA Objects to EPA’s Draft Risk Evaluation of Formaldehyde
AFIA Objects to EPA’s Draft Risk Evaluation of Formaldehyde

The American Feed Industry Association says formaldehyde has been "safely used in the U.S. animal food industry for over 40 years via accurate automated equipment."

Power of Meat Reports Strong Meat Consumption, Evolving Consumer Trends
Power of Meat Reports Strong Meat Consumption, Evolving Consumer Trends

The Meat Institute and FMI-The Food Industry Association released the 19th annual Power of Meat report.

Cattle Imports from Mexico
Cattle Imports from Mexico

Mexico has become one of the major beef import sources for the U.S. as beef trade evolved from simply supplementing deficit beef production in Mexico to bilateral, product specific trade between the two countries.

Markets: Cash Cattle Markets Nearing Historic Highs
Markets: Cash Cattle Markets Nearing Historic Highs

All classes of cattle sold at higher prices for the week and most are at or near record highs. Supplies of all classes remain extremely tight.

International Genetic Solutions Debuts New Informational Resource
International Genetic Solutions Debuts New Informational Resource

International Genetic Solutions (IGS) recently unveiled a new information resource and video platform for important beef industry topics pertinent to producers’ bottom lines.

Sage_Grouse_Booming
Ranchers Urge BLM to Incorporate Latest Science in New Sage Grouse Plans

NCBA and PLC are requesting that BLM significantly extend the comment period deadlines while ranchers and other local stakeholders evaluate these lengthy proposals.