Court Upholds California Proposition 12

Court upholds Proposition 12
Court upholds Proposition 12

Proposition 12, California’s 2018 ballot initiative that bans the sale of meat and eggs derived from producers that don’t meet California standards, was upheld by a panel of judges in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday.

A federal district court had rejected a request by the North American Meat Institute (NAMI) for a preliminary injunction against Proposition 12, and the three-judge panel on the US Court of Appeals upheld that decision. NAMI opposes Proposition 12 because it established meat production standards that apply to producers outside of the state.

“We are disappointed in the ruling and are reviewing our options,” NAMI said. “California should not be able to dictate farming practices across the nation.”

California voters approved the Prevention of Cruelty to Farm Animals Act (Proposition 12) in 2018, which stipulates farmers must provide 43 square feet of floor space for calves, 24 square feet for pigs and more than one foot for hens. NAMI argued that Proposition 12 violates the commerce clause of the U.S. Constitution through what amounts to a trade barrier, and that California law should not affect meat producers outside of the state.

U.S. District Judge Christina Snyder disagreed, saying the law doesn’t prevent out-of-state businesses from selling their products outside of California. The Ninth Circuit court agreed, ruling that Proposition 12 “does not have a discriminatory purpose given the lack of evidence that the state had a protectionist intent,” and in determining that NAMI was unlikely to succeed on the merits of its commerce clause claim.

The California campaign for Proposition 12 was led by the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS), and the ballot initiative passed with 63% of the vote.

Related stories:

Meat Institute Seeks To End California's Proposition 12


Latest News

Winter cattle feeding
Cash Cattle Weaker As Grain Rallies

Cash cattle prices slipped lower throughout the week as packer demand was called moderate. Grain markets posted a significant rally on the heels of USDA's report on Tuesday.

2 hours ago
Packing plant workers
Fired Tyson Managers: ‘Betting Pool’ Stories Distorted

Former Tyson Foods Waterloo, Iowa, plant managers dispute claims of how an "office pool" regarding COVID-19 was portrayed in news stories and deny it was about how many employees would contract the virus.

1 hour ago
Dream Lake with Hallett Peak in the background, at Rocky Mountain National Park.
Hi-Plains Researchers To Help Protect Rocky Mountain National Park

A Texas A&M AgriLife team will work with the Colorado Livestock Association and other stakeholders to refine and evaluate practices to reduce agricultural ammonia emissions into Colorado’s Rocky Mountain National Park.

12 min ago
AL Ranch
Beef. It’s What’s For Dinner. Launches “MBA NextGen”

MBA NextGen updates the popular MBA training modules making it easier than ever for a new generation of farmers and ranchers to share their story and advocate knowledgeably for the beef industry.

8 min ago
Greg Henderson
Overall Meat Sales Higher In 2020

Meat sales - both dollar values and volume - were significantly higher in 2020. Those gains, however, came at the expense of a crippled restaurant and food service industry that may take years to recover.

9 min ago
Progressive Beef
Progressive Beef and Wendy’s® Advance Partnership

Wendy's announces 15% increase in percentage of beef sourced through Progressive Beef-certified producers in 2020; on track to meet goal of at least 50% this year.

14 min ago