GAO Reviews FMD Biosecurity

Following a review, the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) calls for strengthening of the USDA’s process for evaluating foreign animal-health systems and the risk of introducing foot and mouth disease (FMD) from imported beef.

In their report, the GAO notes that federal regulations restrict fresh beef imports from countries where the disease is present because the virus can survive in untreated, uncooked beef, potentially leading to a costly outbreak of disease in U.S. herds. The GAO study examined how the USDA evaluates the animal-health systems in beef-exporting countries and how to improve that process.

The GAO found that the USDA’s process, administered through the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service's (APHIS), currently involves five steps:

1.       A country requests that APHIS evaluate its animal health system.

2.       APHIS gathers information about the country's system, including documents identifying (1) veterinary control and oversight programs, (2) vaccination programs, (3) animal identification and movement controls, (4) laboratory diagnostic capabilities, and (5) animal-disease emergency-response measures.

3.       APHIS conducts in-country visits to verify and supplement this information.

4.       APHIS does a risk analysis to determine whether the country's beef products pose a risk to U.S. livestock and begins to draft a risk analysis report.

5.       APHIS determines an estimated risk level, which is included in the risk analysis report with a description of any mitigation measures the country must implement to ensure the safety of its beef exports. A report is completed and made public only for countries whose beef presents low risk. Countries whose beef poses a greater risk will not be eligible to export beef to the United States.

The report’s authors indicate APHIS could strengthen its evaluations by improving transparency to stakeholders. Currently, they note, APHIS does not direct staff to document their analysis of country information and include all problems and concerns identified and how they were resolved, effectively document results of in-country visits or indicate how to incorporate guidance on transparency into final risk analysis reports.

The GAO report provides three broad recommendations for steps the Secretary of Agriculture should take to improve USDA's evaluations of foreign countries' animal health systems.

1.       Direct the Administrator of APHIS to complete its efforts to develop agency guidance, clarifying that (1) staff must document, separately from the final risk analysis report, how key information gathered about a foreign country's animal health system was analyzed and how the information supports each of eight evaluation factors, and (2) in-country site visits must be appropriately and consistently documented in trip reports and should detail verification activities

2.       Direct the Administrator of APHIS to complete its efforts to develop an information management system to better store, organize, and manage documentation gathered about a foreign country's animal health system.

3.       Direct the Administrator of APHIS to develop guidance promoting greater transparency in risk analysis reports in accordance with the quality information guidelines issued by USDA's Chief Information Officer and guidance from the Office of Management and Budget.

The full report is available online from the GAO.



Latest News

Why Drought Could Be a Catalyst for Crop, Cattle Prices in 2021

U.S. farmers are facing a changing scenario this year. From wet conditions impeding planting in 2020, to now drought concerns creeping in, one analyst thinks weather could be a major market mover in 2021.

10 min ago
Cash cattle improve
Hulett: Cash Cattle Gaining Ground

On-feed numbers indicate that packers could be running low on committed cattle, which should force some packers back into the cash market in the coming weeks.

7 min ago
The 3 Stages of Parturition (Calving)

As the calving season approaches, an increased understanding of the parturition process is helpful. The more we understand about the physiology of the process, the more likely we are to make sound decisions.

9 min ago
AL Ranch
Peel: Regional Hay Issues Due to Western Drought

Drought persists across much of the west and has extended into much of the Great Plains, with several states showing the impact of the drought on hay production and supplies and the challenges for cattle producers.

29 min ago
Nebraska Feedlot @TLauritsen
Fed Cattle Steady As Futures Hit 11-Month High

Cattle feeders were left on the sidelines as every other cattle/beef market segment saw a price rally. Futures markets set new highs, but cash cattle have not reached $112 for seven months.

18 hours ago
Cargill Dodge City
Cargill Will Temporarily Idle Two Packing Plants

Cargill announced it will temporarily idle two of its protein processing facilities for scheduled maintenance. The idling of the facilities is unrelated to the COVID-19 pandemic.

19 min ago