Guidelines for Feeding Haylage Versus Hay

( Sponsored Content )

Feeding silage is much different than feeding hay, so it must be managed and handled differently too. Because silage is much wetter than hay, it is much more susceptible to deterioration. Sealed from oxygen during storage, the forage undergoes fermentation. However, once it is again exposed to air as it is fed, it can deteriorate quickly. Because of this, baled silage must be managed slightly differently than hay, according to John Cothren, North Carolina State University Extension.

Whether it is in an upright, bunker, pit, or bag silo or as a wrapped bale, the process of fermentation is very similar. Essentially, bacteria that occur naturally on the surface of dying plant leaves undergo massive population buildups once oxygen is excluded from their environment. They derive energy from the sugars that are inherent in plant cell sap and tissue via a fermentative process. They undergo many, many cycles of feeding and reproduction until their populations become so high that the waste of their fermentation processes leads to a buildup of acid. This is why silage has a low pH. 

The smell of silage is also the byproducts of the fermentation process. Though this silage is produced in bulk in a silo or wrapped bale, the fermentation is essentially the same process that happens on a smaller scale when a ruminant animal such as a cow, sheep or goat ingests the forage. This is why this feed is such a natural fit for dairy, beef, sheep and goat production. Essentially, silage is “pre-ruminated” forage.

But, therein lies the major issue with feeding silage: instability. An analogy to our eating habits would be potato salad. Precooked and prepared, it doesn’t need to sit out very long before we eat it. This is especially true at a summer picnic where temperatures can speed the deterioration. But this can also occur in the wintertime, even though it may take longer for it to spoil. In either case, it is not worth the chance of eating it if it sat out very long.

As a “rule of thumb,” never leave silage exposed to the air more than two days during feeding. If the daytime temperature exceeds 60°F, don’t leave it exposed more than one day. This rule of thumb is especially important for producers who feed baled silage (haylage). It is extremely critical to those who use an in-line bale wrapper, since this determines the feedout rate. 

If you have made baled silage using an in-line bale wrapper, you must be feeding enough animals that you can feed at least one bale per day in the winter. This is because as a bale is fed, the next bale is being exposed to air. Individually wrapped bales are usually not subject to exposure before they are fed, and thus the feeding schedule is somewhat more flexible.

Here are some additional “rules of thumb” on how to feed silage bales or, in some cases, what not to do:

•    Ensure that the storage site doesn’t increase the chances of exposure to air. Some storage sites increase the likelihood of punctures to the plastic wrap. Examples would be areas near trees that have dropped limbs, rodent and other varmint dens, or that are freshly mowed and have coarse weed stubble. Many of these may create punctures that go unnoticed until it is too late.

•    Ensure that the forage is between 45% and 65% moisture before it is wrapped and ensiled. Baling when the crop is too dry is the most common problem because a field may start out at the right moisture and end up being too dry. Dry forage doesn’t provide the bacteria enough moisture to allow sufficient fermentation. But it does allow fungi to grow during storage and feeding that can lead to deterioration. Baling too wet is less common. However, high-moisture silage spoils more quickly when exposed to air.

•    Don’t spear into bales after they have been wrapped. Squeeze carriers or handlers are better, but they may still stretch, tear or puncture bales. Any hole in the plastic barrier can lead to small areas or even entire bales that deteriorate.

•    To feed a bale that has been wrapped using an in-line wrapper, simply spear into the bale, lift and pull away. The plastic between it and the next bale will tear away. Then cut over the top and peel the plastic off in one large section. To feed an individually wrapped bale, cut a large X in the end to be speared and pull back the flaps. Spear the bale, lift and cut across the top and down the other flat side to peel the plastic off in one piece. In both cases, twine should then be removed before placing in the paddock and placing a feeding ring around the bale.

•    The ensiling process is usually complete within two to six weeks, depending on a large number of factors. Yet, at essentially any point, the forage can be fed. The feeding rate should still be relatively quick, however, as excessive heating, as well as spoilage, could be significant if exposed for days or even hours.

You can find the full article here.
Originally published in December 2014 by John Cothren with North Carolina State University Extension


John Cothren
John Cothren, North Carolina State University Extension

To read more articles like this one:


Winter Feeding Hay in the Field
Sampling Forage and Feed
Surviving the Next Four Months in Three Steps for Cattle Producers

Dairy Herd Management

Baleage is Different Than All Other Forage Making Practices
The Cost of a Windrow
Capture Haylage Quality


Sponsored by Lallemand Animal Nutrition