Dan Murphy: PETA Slams on Sled Dogs

PETA claims the iconic race, the Iditarod, is cruel and inhumane. ( Freeimages.com )

It may not occupy the top shelf in bars or liquor stores, but Jack Daniel’s whiskey is in the forefront of the news this week.

That’s because the well-known brand will no longer be a sponsor of Alaska’s Iditarod Trail Sled Dog Race, according to a statement.

The departure by Louisville, Ky.-based parent company Brown-Forman capped a difficult year for organizers of the 1,000-mile race, an event that has long sparked controversy and which had been confronted with the loss of other sponsors, as well as an alleged “dog doping” scandal.

According to a statement by spokesman Svend Jansen, Jack Daniel’s “decided to go a different direction” by shifting its marketing efforts to a partnership with the National Basketball Association. He added that the anti-Iditarod campaign conducted by People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals “had nothing to do with the decision” to drop its sponsorship.

“As a sponsor of the Iditarod for 15 years, we have been particularly impressed with the utmost care in which the animals are treated by the race veterinarians, the dog sled teams and everyone associated with this event,” Jansen noted in an email published by the Associated Press.

Of course, our pals at PETA were quick to claim credit for the whiskey maker’s departure — and to take their criticism of the race over the top.

As usual.

‘Countless’ canine fatalities?
“After hearing from more than 186,000 PETA members and supporters and being the target of public protests for more than a year, Jack Daniel’s will no longer sponsor the Iditarod,” PETA stated in a website post. “The company joins Guggenheim Partners, State Farm, Wells Fargo and others in ending its support for this egregiously cruel race.”

“This is a victory for all the dogs who’ve been forced to run this cruel race,” added Tricia Lebkuecher, a PETA spokesperson, in an interview with AP.

Did they mention the race is cruel?

The activist group claimed that five dogs connected with the 2017 race died and “countless others have died while chained up in the cold or been killed simply because they weren’t fast or fit enough to race.”

Really? “Countless dogs” died while chained up or because they couldn’t compete?

First of all, dogs with the breeding and physiology to pull a sled generally cost between $2,000 and $5,000 apiece. Since most teams bring 14 or 15 dogs to the Iditarod, the team alone can cost upwards of $60,000 or $70,000 plus, in addition to tens of thousands more for food, vet bills, clothing and equipment.

Is it really plausible that mushers who’ve made that kind of an investment would simply let their dogs die while “chained up in the cold” or kill them because they weren’t fast enough?

As opposed to PETA’s warped perspective on dog racing, here’s what actually goes on with the training of a sled dog capable of competing in a race such as the Iditarod.

Preparations begin a year ahead of time and by December, teams are covering between 25 and 75 miles a day, four or five times a week, according to an article on the Alpine Publications website titled, “What it Takes to Prepare for the Iditarod.”

“Mushers pair dogs carefully by size, conformation, build, gait and attitude to achieve synchrony of pace (dogs that match each other’s stride),” the article explained. “By observing the dogs’ ears, heads and tails, the musher learns to recognize when they are tired, when they are slacking off, and when they are under too much pressure.”

By January and February (the Iditarod runs in early March), mushers have typically logged several thousand miles of training runs and have usually competed in other long-distance races, as well. According to the late Susan Butcher, who won the Iditarod four times and in 1979 was the first person to scale Alaska’s 20,310-foot Denali (Mount McKinley) with a dog team, “A winning dog is made, not born. It isn’t magic. It’s just work and work and work and work.”

That work, Butcher emphasized, must include “attention to the dogs’ mental and physical health, as well as careful conditioning.” As a result of their conditioning, according to the author of the book, “A Fan’s Guide to the Iditarod,” a trained sled dog “will be able to trot at 10 miles per hour, lope at 14 miles per hour, and maintain an average speed of 11 miles per hour over the nearly 1,200 miles of the Iditarod.”

As for the “countless dog deaths,” according to the Anchorage Daily News, a total of 17 dogs have died during the last 10 years of racing, with two of those deaths due to overheating during the plane ride home and another two in which dogs were hit by spectators riding snow machines. None died from being chained up in the cold or simply run to death, as PETA claimed.

Leaving aside the historical significance of the Iditarod, which commemorates the famous 1925 “Great Race of Mercy,” in which teams of sled dogs relayed life-saving diphtheria antitoxin to the remote Alaskan town of Nome — a statue of Balto, the lead dog in the team that finally reached the town, was erected the following year in New York’s Central Park — the mushers and the dog teams participating in the event take it seriously and approach it as professionals.

The dogs themselves are trained athletes that are as eager to run as human competitors are to get out on the football field or behind the wheel of a stock car, events that also result in occasional fatalities that seemingly don’t concern PETA at all.

Unless a bird or a bison serves as some team’s mascot, in which case, PETA would say, that’s an outrage that must be stopped!

Editor’s Note: The opinions in this commentary are those of Dan Murphy, a veteran journalist and commentator.


Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
7 + 7 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
Submitted by Simon Ritchie on Fri, 06/29/2018 - 12:24

What does this have to do with agriculture?

(Apart from the woman's surname of Butcher...)

Submitted by Liz Yogerst on Fri, 06/29/2018 - 13:29

Because PETA is a pain in the butt for anyone with animals.
If agriculture is seen to include raising purpose-bred animals for a specific activity, it can include sled dogs. Creating a team may take work, but it also starts with a type of dog that is a far cry from the Malamutes and Huskies used in the original serum delivery. Developing distance racers takes every bit as much effort as perfecting food-production animals or racehorses..

In reply to by Simon Ritchie (not verified)

Submitted by LeeAnn Baker on Sat, 06/30/2018 - 11:52

This is not journalism, you are a fiction writer Dan. Just look at any of the images of these dogs vomiting up blood, dying from exhaustion and pneumonia and the conditions they are CHAINED UP 24/7 in all year round, never allowed inside. Some are not even Huskies, the owner of Windrift Kennels in Ontario got one of her lab-pointer mixes from a Human Society. And, in the original serum race, those animals were refreshed with a new team of dogs at each check point, they didn't run the WHOLE race themselves. So, check the pictures Dan, images don't lie, and you can't construe them.

Submitted by Spaniel land on Sun, 07/01/2018 - 02:39

Do you know how many animals PETA euthanizes a year? And how many they adopt. Only 1% of animals in their care actually get adopted. Thats over 100,000 dogs, puppies, kittens, and cats that are killed by PETA. The cruelty is not with responsible dog owners who choose to run a race with dogs that are bred for it. The cruelty is with the wolf slaughtering inocent lives while blaming it on others. Im a alaskan, and I have been to multiple mushing lots. From spint racers to long distance racers. Never once have I seen a dog forced to pull a sled. Nor have I seen blood. Nor has anyone killed a dog for being slow. Its just the same as PETA saying farmers kill their sheep for wool. It does not make sense to kill something you spend so much money on and is extremely difficult to get. PETA enjoys fabracating lies. They lie about being for the rights of animals, when actually they want to end all dog ownership and have dogs live in the wild. They feel its cruel for any animal to a loving pet. Maybe think before you comment something so uneducated.

In reply to by LeeAnn Baker (not verified)

Submitted by LeeAnn on Tue, 07/03/2018 - 12:49

First of all, these sled dogs ARE chained up 24/7 all year round, I can't attach images, just google images of former "Champion" racer Lance Mackey, with only a lousy wooden hut for shelter, and google bloody-chained-dog.jpg to see a dog suffering from severe diarrhea during this race. As far as the person who commented that commercially used animals are somehow TRAINED to be hooked up to a machine their whole lives, guess what?, A cow is cow, a dog is a dog and that will not change no matter how much you make them suffer, they will all succumb to abuse the same. Blood WILL still solidify at the same frigid temperature and heat stroke will still overcome them at the same way no matter they are "WORKING' animals or not. These dogs freeze to death on these concentration camps waiting for this highlight of their lives- the big race. They are not soul less shells to pull around men in a pissing contest. My neighbors dog jumped over 2 fences into a pool three houses down to save a toddler he sensed was drowning in a pool , jumped in and saved him. He got a metal from the city. We underestimate dogs so much. Why don't these men challenge each other on snowmobiles if they want to prove to each other who is the biggest, winner of the pick up truck? And I am not a member of PETA and don't think all dogs should be wild! WHAT is that?
And no-one has agreed that the original serum race had fresh teams of dogs at each check point, NOT the same ones the whole way, cause they knew that was wrong.

In reply to by Spaniel land (not verified)

Submitted by Spaniel Land on Sun, 07/01/2018 - 02:31

PREACH!!!!! I love articles like this!!! Solid facts!!!

Submitted by Tom Hogan on Mon, 07/02/2018 - 08:26

Jack Daniel's Black Label , , Fits the NBA
Dumb move The NBA is losing viewers just like the NFL

Submitted by Victoria on Sat, 07/07/2018 - 07:19

My name is Victoria , I never thought I will smile again, My husband left
me with two kids for one year, All effort to bring him back failed I
thought I’m not going to see him again not until I met a lady called
Jesse who told me about a spell caster called dr.alusistanley, She
gave me his email address and mobile number and I contacted him and he
assured me that within 3days my husband will come back to me, In
less than 3days my husband came back started begging for forgiveness
saying it is the devils work, so I’m still surprise till now about
this miracle,i couldn’t conceive but as soon as the spell was cast,i
became pregnant and gave birth to my third child(Michelle) if you need
any assistance from him you can contact him via:email

Submitted by Daniel Ford on Mon, 07/16/2018 - 15:39


Do you need funding to start-up or expand a business?

We give out all kind of loan like:
Business loan
Personal loan
Home loan
Agricultural loan
Educational loan
Auto loan and other good Reason.

With over 10 years of experience helping people acquire, recover and stay in their homes and expand/start their business.
We help new entrepreneur and smart business owners to grow with adequate finance. Contact us at Ford Credit Centre LLC a private lending firm registered in Atlanta.

We give you quality service and our interest rate is calculated at 3% per annul.

If you are interested send us a mail for the prerequisite to begin the funding process.

Kind Regards
Daniel Ford
Ford Credit Centre LLC
409.293.4195 cell
404.400.4210 whatsapp